I don't think so, obviously never been there!
Drs need to practice health, at no point should they be trying to weigh in on immigration policy. If Drs so concerned for the health of these people they can always go buy a air ticket and do a home visit!
Oh my!
What a load of rubbish
That AMA dr should get gassed, might change his shitty thoughts on the matter
Well this is a guy, who's greatest challenge is how to get as many people through his practice each day and how to maximise his kickbacks from drug makers....its hilerous when these idiots speak....Smart isnt spelt 'D' 'O' 'C' 'T' 'O' 'R'.
So we don't put border security into the hands of the AMA. If Phelps understood this consequence, she will lose her electorate fairly soon.
What a great lot of Australian Doctors... NOT...
The naivety of this doc to the realities of history is appaling - she needs to be condemned for deliberate exaggeration and stirring community anguish
With such an obvious misinterpretation of history, how could anyone trust his word, let alone judgement.
JBOZALCIBIADES Monumentally stupid comment by an educated doctor. Who says educated people can't be stupid.
Such a sad, terrible and shameful breech of human rights 😢
How the hell would he know? He was there? Disgraceful.
Disgusting comment.
Auschwitz comparisons ilinformed overreach-politics aside-surely no citizen believes fellow humans shouldn’t receive medical care if it’s vital and available-read the proposed amendment 198D & advisory panel 199B-compassion AND border protection can coexist
'You're going to the gas chamber soon' 'Well that's a relief, at last I know what's happening' Yes such comforting words. This doctor needs to see a doctor.
Yeah I can see the similarities. Air conditioning, three squares a day, beds, showers, TV, access to free health care. No gas chambers, incinerators, torture or firing squads. Pretty much exactly NOT like Auschwitz in anyway. Ill informed or ignorant Doctor.
What a despicable person.
plus , wilful waste of taxpayer money.
Australia is supposed to be a civilised country and yet we torture and murder asylum seekers...
And u want these doctors deciding what refugees come to Australia !
Having visited Dachau concentration camp on boxing day and seeing first hand what happened there and at the other camps in the Nazi 'system', I am confident in declaring this Dr is a flog.
Really. Unbelievable comment.
Paul Bauert should be charged with treason
The historical ignorance is astounding.
'Oh, that's a relief - I thought we were in real trouble!' said nobody in a Holocaust gas chamber, ever.
Perhaps fortuitously today the AMA by that stupid Auschwitz holocaust comparison by a senior paediatrician they have really highlighted their lack of credentials for the responsibility they demand of deciding who should come to Australia. auspol
Boganiser I’d say he’s found relief... knowing he is losing his marbles and has to step down! LastStand
Propaganda bullshit...
What a disgusting mindset for a Doctor to have.
He must resign or be booted either way he must go!
Irrespective of politics, motives for action need to prioritize humanitarian needs. Then security issues. Hyperbolic grandstanding has no place. None of the parties (current govt, impending govt or AMA) have slightest clue how to deal with this. Get some proper advice, please.
The AMA are just becoming a parody of themselves. It's about time these medical practitioners came down from their rarified air & participated in the real world. They are ridiculously out of touch.
So doctors want to control our borders well let them put their hand in the pocket to save the tax payer and open up their house
These loonies just keep popping up from under any rock. I mean how can they get away with saying such offensive lies. And of course their lefty media friends lap it up.
auspol Doctor Phelps is no better than the NAZIS in joining with the GREENS + LABOR, Knowing the last LABOR govt LURED refugees to get in leaky boats, when 1200 of these drowned, is she happy with this, is she DOCTOR DEATH.
wtf ?
Thats the level of intelligence of the doctors signing the get up petition.
Let’s just set the Narrative, pro Globalist The Australian so predictable.
Doctors are like bankers, they have become salesmen selling us drugs or procedures or in this case whatever it takes to suck off the public purse. Doctors have not been elected to make decisions on who will come to auspol drkerrynphelps ama_media
Godwin’s law getting a real work out lately!
Awful thing to say.
THIS is the CRAZY BRIGADE wanting to circumvent our NATIONAL SECURITY. Be warned, these rampant union Commies will , with Labor, dismantle ANY border security arrangements in place and make a REFUGEE SUPERHIGHWAY straight to CENTRELINK, the promised land.
should be sacked
I wonder why people don’t trust the AMA? 🤔
Great media bite but if do-gooders want to worry about something, plenty to worry about within Australia.
I think it's ill informed doctors of this ilk, that Phelps is hoping will examine the new country shoppers.
No words! 😳
Don't know the answer but no border integrity is not one of them.
They should be ashamed. Disgusting.
Looks like 99.9 of the response is against this silly Doc. Moved on , this is a non news!
Exaggeration. When labels such as these ,including Nazis, Hitler, Holocaust etc are used wrecklessly, the general population becomes numb, turned away and the argument is lost. Bad communication skills full of hype.
EliGreenblat Abhorrent and insensitive comment in the extreme.
Must be a leftist.
Leftie is as lefties does
5% of registered doctors signed on online petition against asylum seekers being kept on Nauru and Manus. Less than the Green's primary vote. 1 in 20. You've got better odds doctor shopping for Oxy.
Would these be some of the same doctors that turn a blind eye to FGM & child marriage, allow people to be on disability support because their wives are too anxious to mix with society and assess men old enough to grow beards as children?
Disgusting propagandists man. No Dr.
Having a medical degree obviously has know bearing on intellect otherwise these mindless ‘woke folk’ wouldn’t be making these ridiculous assumptions!
Really? Are children experimented on? Are people gassed WITHOUT knowing ? Shot? Starved to death? Made to dig their own graves before death? Peoples skin was used to make lampshades...does that happen? The doctor should be disciplined for ignorant comments like that.
Don't you love the stethoscopes around their necks?
These are no 'doctors'. Just a bunch of self serving individuals with their own agendas standing under a banner that says 'doctors'
Really - Doctors being Politicians
Let’s make this doctor be one of the guys that chooses whether people can come in to our country. He sounds balanced.
Bloody bleeding snowflakes, you have to be loosing it big time, really we have treated them like the Nazi really
It's just not the same when a novice pulls a well rehearsed established Guilt trip sympathy ploy...
Liberals are jumping up and down on their success of border protection. It's a shameful account of this matter.
What a crackpot
what a stupid doctor how come all the local people have survived if it is so bad, also why did they not go home like many did. Taxpayers are keeping many foreigners against their will as taxes are being misused without their permission. If people want to keep them volunteer n pay
Hand in your licence and seek treatment
Comparisons with the holocaust is disgraceful, they have lost my support completely. Men & women ded in the death camps, more men & women died trying to end that murderous regime who's plan was world wide murder. Disgraceful loathsome comparison.
What a incompetent fool, unless the so called AMA doctor was in the living areas of the Holocaust this fool would never know what Jews felt like being gassed to death.
JBOZALCIBIADES He is obviously antisemitic too since he is frivolously diminishing the extreme horror of the Holocaust.
JBOZALCIBIADES Doctors are more corruptable than prostitutes. But unlike doctors, prostitutes are upfront about it and don’t assume high moral ground.
Bet he’s a card carrying member of the greens !
What an ignorant offensive piece of sh*t that doctor is. Did the left activists learn nothing from people’s response when one of their clan last compared Manus to the holocaust!
You r fucking kidding me
JBOZALCIBIADES Ohhh wow spare us all from this obviuos load of BS , to compare Nauru to concentration camps is just pure evil socialist rubbish
This doctor is a complete idiot and ones wonders whether he/she is a fit person to remain a doctor. We treat the refugees on Nauru too good as seen by 40+ refugees resettled in the USA want to return to Nauru. What jews wanted to return to the gas chamber? We are too good !!
Gee and I thought only lawyers were dumb ...
this is classic Hard Left propaganda yet again smearing people who died in the Holocaust how dare these lying leftist pricks dictate to us what we should do!
If only a LNP member or Govt official had said that. australian auspol
Haven’t we already crossed this bridge with a looney Anglican Priest recently...using the Nazi card as a comparison tool displays all the hallmarks of a deeply deranged individual. I’d be happy to meet with these “doctors” and explain how my family was impacted by genocide.
We will take this with a grain of salt. These people really are barking up the wrong tree by coming out of the woodworks to support this stupid bill from Karyn Phelps.
What a disgrace by Australia Doctors
so she was in auschwitz
Sounds like a reasonable man that makes informed judgements 🤦♂️
If I was a holocaust survivor I'd punch this guy in the face.
Do not conflate education with intelligence.
Doctors MUST not be allowed to decide who comes to Australia or not. You have just shown that you are biased with regard to this situation. You must ask yourself if you believe in the security department 'ASIO' to vet these people, if not , why not. You are not ELECTED REPS
Quite possibly the most disturbing thing I've ever heard!!!!!! Thank God I'm not under his care!
One has to ask, do doctors believe there is no dirt available to be thrown at them. They are people in business, many have the same moral standards as bankers, they lie, cheat and rob the taxpayer daily, they kill people. They really are taking a risk here.
Look at this pack of numbskulls....^^^^^^^^^^^^
Finding equivalence when unequivocally there is none will end up in tears!
Hahahaha This is insultingly hilarious..I didn't know they have gas chambers and execution squads on Nauru? lol..
You know when the left are loosing the argument... they resort to the lowest of the low.
Say that a little louder!
Getting hysterically out of hand
Health Health Latest News, Health Health Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Source: abcnews - 🏆 5. / 83 Read more »
Source: smh - 🏆 6. / 80 Read more »
Source: SkyNewsAust - 🏆 7. / 78 Read more »
Source: SBSNews - 🏆 3. / 89 Read more »
Source: SkyNewsAust - 🏆 7. / 78 Read more »
Source: smh - 🏆 6. / 80 Read more »